‘Community photojournalism shows how we all have more in common than we think’: How Mirror Indy reflects Indianapolis

At Mirror Indy, visual storytelling is about more than strong images — it’s about helping Indianapolis residents see themselves and one another more clearly.

That approach has become a defining part of the newsroom’s identity. Readers often recognize Mirror Indy not only because of its bright green branding, but because of its consistent focus on real people and authentic moments.

“Community photojournalism shows how we all have more in common than we think,” said Art Director Jenna Watson. “It’s easy to turn away from statistics and headlines, but when we see a person’s face wrinkles or hear the inflections in their voice, we soften and see their humanity. It’s a powerful entry point to any news story.”

Mirror Indy experiments with new visual formats to make local issues more accessible and engaging. One recent example involved a video explaining how data centers work using handheld props and visual demonstrations.

“Some of our least conventional visual storytelling has been what resonated with neighbors most,” Watson said. “We want to make stories that actually catch the attention of everyday people, not just other journalists. Getting more help in those departments will be a gamechanger and let us get weird with it more often.”

That willingness to experiment shapes how CatchLight Local and Report for America fellow Brett Phelps approaches community-centered photography in Indianapolis.

His work moves through moments of tension and celebration alike, documenting everyday life with an emphasis on emotion and presence. Rather than observing from a distance, he focuses on building trust within the communities he photographs.

“One thing that Mirror Indy covers really well is civic engagement in our community. From data centers, to walkouts, or the redistricting battle, I have been able to shine a light on how our community feels through my images,” Phelps said.

For Phelps, that work requires consistency, especially when covering events where the most meaningful moments are not always immediately visible.

“My goal is to make images and videos that preserve the history of today for the generations of tomorrow,” he said. “Too, I am the eyes and ears for people who cannot be in ‘the room where it happens,’ to quote the musical ‘Hamilton.’”

After months of documenting life in Indianapolis, Phelps says one truth continues to stand out.

“The people here are what makes my career so rewarding,” Phelps said. “They are caring and passionate about making this city the best that it can be. At the end of the day, I know that as long as I have the back of the community, they will have my back, too.”

SEE MORE IMAGES BY BRETT PHELPS IN THE GALLERY BELOW OR VISIT MIRRORINDY.ORG.