The search for ‘Our Democracy’ with photojournalist Andrea Bruce

After 15 years documenting wars in Iraq, Afghanistan and other regions, photojournalist Andrea Bruce focused her lens on a growing political conflict at home.

Coal miners in Buchanan, Virginia, work with headlamps in a dark underground tunnel
Coal miners in Buchanan, Virginia, are among the rural voters Andrea Bruce interviewed for her visual reporting project, Our Democracy, following the 2016 U.S. elections. © Andrea Bruce / Our Democracy

“As someone who is from the United States, a country that kind of exports this idea of democracy to different places, I would often get these questions about its meaning,” she says. “But after so many years overseas, I didn’t feel like I even had a solid understanding.”

Andrea Bruce speaks on a microphone on stage with David Rodrígez Muñoz and Jeremy Hay
Andrea Bruce speaks at the CatchLight Visual Storytelling Summit on April 18, 2022. Also pictured: 2019 CatchLight Local Fellow, David Rodríguez Muñoz (left), and former Director of Audience and Memberships for CatchLight Local, Jeremy Hay. © Carla Hernández Ramírez

Following the 2016 U.S. elections, Bruce channeled her curiosity into Our Democracy, an ethnographic study and collaborative media project that seeks answers to the question — “What does democracy mean to you?” — by inviting people around the country to share their stories and perspectives.

“I didn’t have a theory I was trying to prove, just this very open-ended question,” she says, noting one of the project’s early challenges. “Go to a newspaper or a magazine for support, and they ask, ‘Okay, what are you going to photograph? What are you going to say?’ But I really didn’t know what I was going to find.”

A voter in Angola, Indiana, prepares to cast a ballot in the 2018 U.S. midterm elections. © Andrea Bruce / Our Democracy

Bruce spent the next year documenting working-class life in dozens of cities and towns. Then in 2018, she was selected for the CatchLight Global Fellowship with a plan that included more interviews, classroom workshops, and community photo submissions. And as the 2020 elections approached, National Geographic picked up the story as an extended photo feature.

The tour eventually led Bruce back to her hometown in Pamlico County, North Carolina, where another question came into focus:

Is democracy even possible without local journalism?

During a stop in San Francisco, a conversation with CatchLight CEO Elodie Mailliet Storm inspired Bruce, the traveled journalist, to embrace a hyperlocal approach.

Last year, Bruce launched Down in the County, a visual newsletter that uncovers hidden stories and daily happenings around Pamlico County, which serves as the only source of local news for the rural community.

“The inspiration behind it really came from CatchLight,” says Bruce. “It’s given me an offshoot to the project that allows me to experience for myself how to grow an audience that doesn’t really trust the news anymore, or how to grow local journalism in a news desert.”

Captain Charles Williams, Jr. stands in the the doorway to the deck of his fishing boat in Pamlico County, North Carolina. Climate change and economic hardship have taken a toll on the region’s commercial fishing industry. © Andrea Bruce / Down in the County

Today, the newsletter reaches almost 5,000 subscribers, an audience roughly 40% the size of Pamlico County’s population, with the majority of readers being local residents. Bruce is encouraged by the response thus far, with an active readership that consistently outperforms media and publishing industry benchmarks.

Focusing on local stories has been both grounding and surprising for Bruce:

“Nationally, we seem so politically charged right now, and it is scary to listen to at times. But realistically, talking to people on the ground, living their lives across the country, people have way more in common than I realized.”

Students say the pledge of allegiance before class begins at the Lydia Patterson Institute in El Paso, Texas.
Students recite the pledge of allegiance before class begins at the Lydia Patterson Institute in El Paso, Texas. El Paso is known to have some of the nation’s lowest voter turnout. Restrictive voting laws in Texas and other conservative states are disenfranchising many citizens, including active long-time voters. © Andrea Bruce / Our Democracy

Bruce’s next objective is to find a new home for the newsletter, which is currently licensed to Bulletin, Facebook’s newsletter subscription pilot that is scheduled for sunset in 2023. Her goal is to find institutional partners to plant deep and lasting roots for local news in Pamlico County.

By collaborating with entities like the local community college, she hopes to deepen her neighbors’ appreciation for honest visual journalism — “not just for people to take it in, but for more people to produce it,” she says.

Andrea’s approach is unique in that she is leveraging her proven visual journalism skills to bring critical information to a county that has no other local news sources. She is creating a new model for other journalists working in news deserts. We have so much to learn from her as we set out to harness the unique power of images to inform and engage the public.

— Elodie Mailliet Storm, CEO, CatchLight

Related Content: Andrea Bruce has News for her Small-town neighbors